138 Comments
User's avatar
misomiso's avatar

Great to have you back Dom.

RockyLives's avatar

Bring on the start-up Dom. Quickly!

TheKnowing's avatar

I'm ready to serve in your start up upon your command sir. I hope not to be forgotten.

TheKnowing's avatar

PS: Will this start up involve Electoral Candidates or are we skipping Westminster? Also councils and regional parliaments. Yes or no?

anna c's avatar

read the Balaji section and the whole Balaji bit to see what it may look like

TheKnowing's avatar

I really hope rampant digitisation isn't the order of the day

anna c's avatar

dunno about rampant but digitisation enables etsy to compete with amazon...

Dan Lucraft's avatar

I was struck today that Truss apparently said several times on the radio that no family’s bill will be higher than £2500, which is not true.

Some possibilities:

- she was lying, as people are already claiming. I find that hard to believe. Why bother?

- she mispoke. But several times? Knowing this is a common misperception?

So we’re left with: she doesn’t know the first thing about her flagship energy policy.

I mean ... that’s it, isn’t it.

NE - Naked Emperor Newsletter's avatar

It seems like she's even less over the details than Boris was. At least he managed to bluff his way out, Truss just malfunctions until rebooted.

anna c's avatar

"No, he wants to be motorbiking around Chequers again in the spring as Dylan chases the new lambs, striding around Kiev striking faux-Churchill poses, quoting Homer on hubris and rebirth"...surely you mean Xmas. By the way 'systems and systems management' seems to have been subcontracted out (corpshored?) to by and large any large company with teeth and a plan. ' Liz e want x y and z by teatime get it done' (FX and Hedgies this week).Energy cos last month, probs food/large ag next, followed by water (bit thirsty anyone-plenty of water in the River Nidd). Is n10 not just pretending to be boss. Isn't the boss the latest man in a suit with shareholders to feed? Doesn't that lead to Marcel Marceau levels of pretend from a 'cabinet', PM etc...who is stage managing?

NE - Naked Emperor Newsletter's avatar

Dom Cummings translator - the UK is fu**ed! It sounds like no 10 could do with some BC-like software to allow them to deal with crises more efficiently.

Reading the FT this week (actually most of the time) is so frustrating. Bad budget = BREXIT, markets crashing = BREXIT, Pensions over-leveraged = BREXIT, nordstream explosion = BREXIT, Eurozone imploding = BREXIT! Do they actually believe this stuff!?

On nordstream - what is your take on who is most likely responsible, Dom?

Also, I agree with a lot of what you write but on lockdowns and warp speed, do you not think back and ponder over whether these were the correct decisions? You criticise what is going on now (which is fair enough) but a lot of this is knock-on effects from economies shutting down for 2 years (which you had a lot of influence over).

Dominic Cummings's avatar

yes they believe it.

being anti-brexit is the religion in many places for these secular graduates

RockyLives's avatar

Like many, the FT has allowed Brexit Derangement Syndrome to tarnish its reputation .

jeremy1113's avatar

The events of 2016 caused most of the FT's columnists what appeared to be a nervous breakdown. Only John Kay seemed to maintain his equanimity and perceptiveness.

John R Ramsden's avatar

Not just the FT. Private Eye has been tarnished, I reckon, by its blatantly anti-Brexit stance ever since the referendum. I can't believe its previous editor, Richard Ingrams, would have made that mistake, whatever his personal feelings about Brexit.

As for the Nordstream sabotage, it's as plain as a pikestaff the Yanks were behind it, to prevent the EU wobbling on sanctions and agreeing a gas deal with Russia. Even most Daily Mail commenters, not always the most perspicacious bunch, twigged that without having to be told! Why would the Russians have done it when they control the taps, unless perhaps it was a crafty double bluff to discredit the US and divide them from the EU?

Tom Scrace's avatar

Dominic - re your comment on Twitter "CANCEL SUBSCRIPTIONS TO NEWSPAPERS". I agree, but what's your preferred source of day-to-day reporting? Twitter/substack etc good for insights and commentary, but not so much basic reporting.

misomiso's avatar

A request from a subscriber - some of us aren't on twitter and hate it so can't follow all your tweets! Updates on here are very much appreciated. Best ty

Al's avatar

You need to write on what your preferred UKR/RUS policy is. I completely understand the massive problems of current situation (nuclear risk, energy prices) but I don't know what your argument actually is.

RockyLives's avatar

The UK Productivity Growth chart included in the blog shows a steady increase until around 2009, after which it flatlines. The period of non-growth correlates almost exactly with an era of massive money-printing (following the financial crash, then Covid, now the energy crisis).

Does this correlation represent causation (even partially)?

Dominic Cummings's avatar

dunno.

it must at least partly reflect financial services getting crushed by regulation (some good some awful)

Jonny M's avatar

As you say, this is a hugely important problem, maybe the most imortant of them all. What was the UK govt theory on the productivity gap when you were there? A measurement issue or UK genuinely less productive than peers?

Stu255's avatar

Wow, OPEC+ cutting 2 million barrels per day just a week after the US ends the SPR release of 1 million barrels per day means that global oil markets just got 3 million barrels per day tighter than they were all throughout the summer.

This means oil prices are going to rally to who knows where, and drag higher all energy markets because everything is effectively benchmarked off the international crude prices specifically Brent and West Texas Intermediate because oil is by far the most liquid and global commodity market.

I would not be surprised to see 25% inflation across Europe within 6 months.

OPEC+ have dealt a huge blow to the West today. Not that anyone in the media recognises this.

Our sovereign debt position is now going to become extremely precarious.

The West is being choked of energy, it's a 21st Century siege.

We are so stupid, we barely recognise who is doing this to us or why.

OPEC+ are betting that following 2 decades of globalisation, the West no longer has the industry to diversify our energy supply in a responsive way, this is where we need to focused right now.

Stu255's avatar

Well a high oil price specifically benefits the OPEC+ nations. It means rivers of capital pouring into OPEC+ nations via trade.

This is a siege now underway against the Washington hegemony (which includes UK and basically all NATO / five eyes). I think siege is the right way to think about it.

For me personally, I think of this Kremlin war mostly being fought in the financial domain. I know the media is entirely focused on geography but I find that quite an antiquated worldview. Still lots of great strategic insights from the history of geographic wars, but it’s just not the primary domain since global financialisation.

Capturing land doesn’t really capture a lot of wealth and power in the modern age. You profit from war by driving markets in predictable ways, or forcing global capital to flow into your accounts, you defeat your enemy in the market first and then you can defeat them geographically.

USA spent $7.5 trillion occupying Afghanistan and believed they were winning the war against the Taliban. They were not. This was exactly the condition Bin Laden sought to achieve, an insanely expensive occupation of nothing.

Money is power. Land is not power.

What I find interesting is to view the world as rivers of capital flows between the major power hubs.

This (in my opinion) is the best framing for geopolitical strategic thinking.

For me, this is the model that best explains everything all the time.

303Bookworm's avatar

Ref: capital as an indicator of power

Tom Luongo makes the case that the Federal Reserve is at war with the European Central Bank.

https://tomluongo.me/2022/08/29/now-everyone-afriad-jerome-powell/

Stu255's avatar

My humble take, of which an unknowable part is certain to be wrong…

That’s a good read, I don’t know that Powell is at war with the ECB or that his policy is pointed at the ECB. But it’s certainly not in anyway accommodative of the ECB. I think Biden’s diplomatic failure to create a real global alliance opposing Russia has made the US prioritise more insular monetary policy.

The same is true of US policy around the SPR release. The US used their SPR to shield themselves from moderate inflationary pressure over summer (their peak energy demand), but in doing so it exposes Europe to huge inflationary pressure over winter (our peak energy demand).

SPR releases probably took $50 off the oil price over the last 6 months and reduced inflation globally by 10% (educated guess) from where it would otherwise have been.

Last week the US stopped their 1million barrels per day SPR release. Taking their foot off global energy inflation.

Then today OPEC+ (which includes Russia) have cut another 2m barrels of crude from the supply chain, sticking an inflationary knife into Europe and twisted it.

Under this pending inflationary environment the EU, which is a monetary Union and not a fiscal Union, is probably going to be torn to pieces.

Under soaring inflation it’s impossible for the ECB to find a common interest rate that satisfies every member state. Some countries will be ruined by inflation, others by the cost of servicing their debt and political pressure for them to exit the EU/eurozone to gain the ability to set their own interest rates will be huge.

Everyone knew the EU would break up under an inflation shock, because it’s an unfinished Union. Those who still believe in their project will try and use the crisis to bind a fiscal union together. That’s going to be one huge fight between unifiers and separatists.

Nobody really expected this to happen so soon. COVID really set all this in motion.

All of this is really uncertain I think, and gets even more uncertain the further ahead you try and think.

But I don’t really think the Ukraine war is about control of Donetsk and Luhansk. It’s about creating a predictable inflation shock with energy supplies and front running the market to make a tide of profit and then buying up all the distressed assets when the inflation fractures Europe open like an egg.

anna c's avatar

or put another way is there any scenario in which the washington hegemony is isolated by all?

anna c's avatar

how do you think the washington hegemony will do...

Stu255's avatar

I think the US (and by extension UK) naturally stay on top because of military supremacy, capitalist prowess and crucially the ability to do power succession, but it’s a question of how much wealth we leak to various despots and trillionaire regimes.

The West’s share of world GDP is falling. Probably because our middle class has failed to compete globally for the last 25 years

Mike's avatar

Dom, regarding the pension fund problems, the opposite is true - they were using derivatives to hedge/protect pensioners’ savings rather than making outsized returns. If they did not, the assets and liabilities would not be matched. What is shocking is regulators’ lack of up to date data on the use of derivatives… They should be on top of this. Good 10 min explanation 35:32-46:00:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RHXIdL0CkYU

Whether derivatives should be used for hedging at all is a different discussion.

Stu255's avatar

All the Kremlin is interested in is controlling the geographical pipeline corridors that connect the huge market that is Europe to the major fossil fuel reserves it demands. Putin isn't following some ideology in his heart, this is a stone cold power calculation. The Kremlin are at war in Ukraine for the same strategic reasons that took them to war in Syria. It's all the same strategic doctrine 'control the pipeline corridors', these are genuinely the choke points of the global economy. Control of these choke points is the absolute foundation of the Kremlin's power. It's not even complicated. It's not new. This simple strategic maxim predict Kremlin behaviour, they don't always get it right, but this is their pole star.

Anyway, this is the USA's strategic petroleum reserve. See how it drops off a cliff?

https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=PET&s=WCSSTUS1&f=W

Why does the Strategic Petroleum Reserve look like that?? This isn't a price chart, it's a stockpile. It shows that the SPR has been depleted by about 30% since Ukraine was invaded. How? Why?

On March 31 2022, Biden announced that his administration would release 1 million barrels of oil per day from the reserve for the next 180 days. Doesn't sound like a big deal until you look at the chart of what this has meant and the historical timescale.

USA has tried to slow their own inflation and also depress energy prices with this historic SPR release. Oil is a globally priced commodity (gas is not), so oil has the ability to lower energy prices everywhere. This has worked to soften the crunch over the course of 2022, especially in USA where energy demand peaks in Summer, unlike Europe where our peak is winter.

The only problem is that the SPR is finite (unlike monetary tools) and as soon as they stop releasing oil from their strategic reserves, energy markets will start to tighten again and prices will start to rise domestically and globally.

When is that?

Well the 180th Day of the SPR release was Tuesday 27th September, which just so happens to be the same day that Russia's two most strategic pipelines (in terms of capital) exploded. Rendering them useless for the foreseeable future.

I suspect somewhere in Washington, there was a cabinet level strategic meeting last week on what to do about current situation with SPR, energy, inflation, Russia, Europe, etc... and the conclusion was to pause SPR release now summer has passed, allow energy markets to tighten and prices to rise, but to avoid Russia from benefiting or strengthening their negotiating position, the Kill-Nordstream option was approved.

On balance, probably the right call for US interests.

303Bookworm's avatar

I don't agree with the analysis that pipeline corridors are the principle lodestar of Russian policy. Ukraine was stealing a LOT of gas from the pipelines running through their territory. After the coup by pro-West activists in 2014, Russia did not invade, but elected to build Nordstream 2 to avoid the bother of having a hostile power tinkering with the supply chain and disrupting economic activity. Russia spent a lot of money to significantly decrease the reliance on gas traffic through that region to avoid a war of economic necessity.

Russia's sensitivity to the Ukraine political situation regarding NATO is more likely down to the fact that several of the principle terrain choke points which would enable Russia to prevent a NATO army marching on Moscow were ***inside Ukraine***. (btw, the current front line is one such choke point. These have been heavily fortified for decades, which goes a long way to explain the abrupt stagnation of the front lines some months ago.) This is why they're all-in on this venture - it is the hard realities of defence policy that cannot be compromised in any way.

Stu255's avatar

I think you have agreed with me?

303Bookworm's avatar

"The Kremlin are at war in Ukraine for the same strategic reasons that took them to war in Syria."

- Syria is not a terrain bottleneck through which a NATO army must pass.

- Long-term disruption of LNG flow by Ukraine was not sufficient cause for war. Russia effectively shrugged and worked around the problem.

Stu255's avatar

“Long-term disruption of LNG flow by Ukraine was not sufficient cause for war. Russia effectively shrugged and worked around the problem.”

Erm, check the news?

My reading is that Russia tried to bypass Ukraine pipeline routes via the Barents Sea. But when that failed, they invaded Ukraine.

Syria is a pipeline corridor from Iraq / Persian Gulf to Turkey. Assad is only in power on the condition that no pipeline ever traverses Syria. Otherwise Arabian or Persian oil & gas could be piped to Europe and complete with Russian pipelines.

anna c's avatar

Senator James Lankford (R-OK) joined Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) and their colleagues to introduce the No Emergency Crude Oil for Foreign Adversaries Act to ensure that reserves sold from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) are not exported to adversarial nations like China. Guess that bill didn't pass in July...

anna c's avatar

Talking about reading lists, in case anyone is interested Marc Andreessen's one... https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1577366618090311681.html

Goro's avatar

Lots of interesting stuff.

Reading James Burnham now.

anna c's avatar

funny you should mention came across an article about him in tablet via other substacks!

Goro's avatar

I’m enjoying The Machiavellians so far…

Wien1938's avatar

I think you're wrong on UKR, Dom. As bad as the West is, Russia at every level is proving to be a shitshow.

The Kharkov collapse was not followed by a cessation of attacks on the Bakhmut front but these continued in intensity, while reinforcements from elsewhere were rushed over and now there's been another debacle at Lymen.

The Russian generals and leadership do not know what they're doing and it shows with mobilisation. It's a desperation move, not to win the war, but to keep the local nobility (rulers of central asian etc( impressed with puissance of Putin.

Russia lacks the ability to sustain a long war and the signs are that their military are cracking.

The Truss Disaster? Boy, is that showing! But then what a crap choice was presented to the Conservative membership. As bad as Truss is, Sunak would have just been a meaner, more stupid Cameron type. If the system is going to collapse, then I'd rather get it over with.

What's that saying from Herodotus? Soft lands breed soft men. We've had soft, easy times for decades and have developed a parasitical governing class in response.

mt99's avatar

Hello Dom. Long time listener, first time caller...

Regarding the "pensions leverage" outrage thing, I would recommend treading carefully as this is not a trivial problem and the set of incentives that gave birth to the recent snafu does not, if considered piece-by-piece, look at all mad. There is a decent thread here: https://twitter.com/danmikulskis/status/1576481071189069824 that describes the "how we got here" quite well, and I really recommend you familiarise yourself with the issue before making radically one-sided judgements...I know, I know, I am here for those as a paid subscriber, but in _this_ case it's not black-and-white. While, yes, levering up pension assets seems mad, not hedging liabilities is comparably mad. And not having enough assets in your pension fund to fully fund its future obligations is not very ideal either. You want to both stabilise your pension fund asset-liability mismatch (as otherwise it can kill the whole business), and to slowly grow the assets to get to 100% level of funding.

So yes, the general level of UK pension funding _is_ something that has to be _much_ better addressed (in both defined-benefit and defined-contribution worlds, and both by the politicians AND the people themselves actually!), the route taken by the funds is not totally without reason if you look at the history of LDI.

It's a bit like salt -- you want some to cook with but perhaps not to eat spoonfuls of.